2020s carbines ranked by empty weight

A ranked look at eight 2020s carbines by empty weight, with the spread, cartridge split and the other figures that move with mass.

This comparison covers eight carbines introduced from 20211 to 2025 and ranks them by empty weight. At the top of the list is the SOLGW MK1 Recce at 3357 g2. At the bottom is the Magpul FDP-9 at 1588 g3. The spread between those endpoints is 1769 g4.

The set is compact enough to read as a whole, and that matters because the ranking itself shows the structure of the group. The heaviest entries sit above 3.2 kg5, the lightest two fall to 2041 g6 and 1588 g, and the middle of the table mixes models that are much closer together. The chart below makes that visible at a glance.

All eight carbines in this ranked set are US designs. That keeps national origin constant and makes the weight differences easier to read against other recorded figures in the catalogue, rather than against different national design traditions. The sections that follow use this order, from heaviest to lightest, as the backbone of the comparison and then relate it to barrel length, cartridge and other recorded specifications.

Empty weight, compared

SOLGW MK1 Recce: 3,357 gSOLGW MK1 Recce3,357 gSOLGW MK1 CAR: 3,311 gSOLGW MK1 CAR3,311 gSOLGW M4-89: 3,221 gSOLGW M4-893,221 gBear Creek Arsenal BC-9: 3,084 gBear Creek Arsenal BC-93,084 gAero Precision EPC-9: 3,005 gAero Precision EPC-93,005 gPSA Sabre-15: 2,948 gPSA Sabre-152,948 gCMMG Banshee Mk17: 2,041 gCMMG Banshee Mk172,041 gMagpul FDP-9: 1,588 gMagpul FDP-91,588 g

Source: GET /v1/firearms/compare?ids=aero-precision-epc-9,magpul-fpc-9,solgw-mk1-recce,bear-creek-bc-9,solgw-m4-89,psa-sabre-15,solgw-mk1,cmmg-banshee-mk17

The data in this chart
FirearmEmpty weight (g)
SOLGW MK1 Recce3,357
SOLGW MK1 CAR3,311
SOLGW M4-893,221
Bear Creek Arsenal BC-93,084
Aero Precision EPC-93,005
PSA Sabre-152,948
CMMG Banshee Mk172,041
Magpul FDP-91,588

The ranked set and the spread

By empty weight, the set runs from the SOLGW MK1 Recce at 3357 g2 down to the Magpul FDP-9 at 1588 g3. In order, the ranking is: SOLGW MK1 CAR at 3311 g7, SOLGW M4-89 at 3221 g5, Bear Creek Arsenal BC-9 at 3084 g8, Aero Precision EPC-9 at 3005 g1, PSA Sabre-15 at 2948 g9, and CMMG Banshee Mk17 at 2041 g6 before the FDP-9 closes the list.

The chart below shows a tight cluster at the top. The MK1 Recce is only 46 g4 heavier than the MK1 CAR, and the MK1 CAR is 90 g heavier than the M4-89. That matters because the three heaviest entries are close enough in mass that they read as a narrow band rather than three widely separated designs.

Lower down, the spacing opens out. The BC-9 sits 137 g above the EPC-9, the EPC-9 57 g above the Sabre-15, and then the largest single step appears: 907 g between the Sabre-15 and the Banshee Mk17. From the Banshee Mk17 to the FDP-9, the gap is 453 g. Across the full ranked set, the spread from 3357 g to 1588 g is 1769 g.

What the heaviest and lightest entries represent

At the top of the ranking, the SOLGW MK1 Recce represents the heaviest end of this 20211 to 2025 set at 3357 g2. It is a 5.56x45mm NATO direct-impingement carbine with a 368 mm barrel, an overall length of 838 mm, a 30-round magazine capacity, a recorded muzzle velocity of 930 m/s and a stated effective range of 500 m.

At the bottom, the Magpul FDP-9 is the lightest entry at 1588 g3. It is a 9x19mm Parabellum blowback carbine with a 178 mm barrel, a 21-round magazine capacity and a stated effective range of 180 m. No overall length or muzzle velocity is recorded for the FDP-9 in this set, which matters when comparing weight against size and output, because the endpoint comparison is complete for some figures and incomplete for others.

The gap between these two endpoints is 1769 g4. Barrel length differs by 190 mm, and magazine capacity differs. The MK1 Recce also carries a recorded muzzle velocity figure of 930 m/s, while the FDP-9 has no recorded muzzle velocity here. Read together, those figures show that the extremes of the ranking are not separated by weight alone, but also by cartridge, dimensions and the completeness of the recorded specification.

Cartridge split behind the weights

The weight ranking splits cleanly by cartridge. The four 9x19mm Parabellum carbines in this set run from the Magpul FDP-9 at 1588 g3 to the Bear Creek Arsenal BC-9 at 3084 g8. The four 5.56x45mm NATO carbines run from the PSA Sabre-15 at 2948 g9 to the SOLGW MK1 Recce at 3357 g2.

That produces two different spreads. The 9x19mm group spans 1496 g4, while the 5.56x45mm group spans 409 g. It also leaves an overlap at the upper end of the 9x19mm class and the lower end of the 5.567 class: 3084 g for the BC-9 against 2948 g for the Sabre-15. So cartridge helps explain the ranking, but does not determine it on its own.

Part of the divide sits in the cartridges themselves. The chart below shows the scale difference in overall length: 57.4 mm10 for 5.56x45mm NATO against 29.69 mm11 for 9x19mm Parabellum. The catalogue’s typical energy figures point the same way, 1767 J for 5.56x45mm NATO and 481 J for 9x19mm Parabellum. In this eight-carbine set, the 5.56 models occupy the heavier half of the table, while the 9x19mm models cover both the lightest entries and part of the middle.

The cartridges, to scale

Drawn from the recorded case and bullet dimensions, all at one scale.

5.56x45mm NATO: 57.4 mm long, 5.7 mm bullet5.56x45mm NATO9x19mm Parabellum: 29.7 mm long, 9 mm bullet9x19mm Parabellum01020304050mm

Source: GET /v1/calibers/5-56x45mm-nato, GET /v1/calibers/9x19mm-parabellum

The data in this chart
CartridgeOverall length (mm)
5.56x45mm NATO57.4
9x19mm Parabellum29.7

Length, barrel and velocity alongside mass

Weight does not map neatly to either recorded length or recorded muzzle velocity. Among the models with an overall length listed, the shortest is the CMMG Banshee Mk17 at 528 mm6, yet it is not the lightest at 2041 g. The longest is the SOLGW M4-89 at 914 mm5, and it sits near the top of the weight ranking at 3221 g rather than at the extreme.

Barrel length shows a similar pattern. The Banshee Mk17 has the shortest recorded barrel at 127 mm. At the other end, the Aero Precision EPC-9, Bear Creek Arsenal BC-9, M4-89 and PSA Sabre-15 all share the longest recorded barrel length in this set at 406 mm1. Even so, their empty weights span from 2948 g9 for the Sabre-15 to 3221 g for the M4-89, a spread of 273 g4 among carbines with the same barrel length.

The velocity figures, shown in the chart below, separate the 5.56x45mm NATO carbines from the recorded 9x19mm Parabellum examples. The EPC-9 is the slowest recorded at 400 m/s, the BC-9 reaches 420 m/s8, the SOLGW entries are listed at 930 m/s2, and the Sabre-15 is highest at 945 m/s. That is a recorded span of 545 m/s from lowest to highest.

Muzzle velocity, compared

2 of the firearms named record no muzzle velocity.

PSA Sabre-15: 945 m/sPSA Sabre-15945 m/sSOLGW M4-89: 930 m/sSOLGW M4-89930 m/sSOLGW MK1 CAR: 930 m/sSOLGW MK1 CAR930 m/sSOLGW MK1 Recce: 930 m/sSOLGW MK1 Recce930 m/sBear Creek Arsenal BC-9: 420 m/sBear Creek Arsenal BC-9420 m/sAero Precision EPC-9: 400 m/sAero Precision EPC-9400 m/s

Source: GET /v1/firearms/compare?ids=aero-precision-epc-9,magpul-fpc-9,solgw-mk1-recce,bear-creek-bc-9,solgw-m4-89,psa-sabre-15,solgw-mk1,cmmg-banshee-mk17

The data in this chart
FirearmMuzzle velocity (m/s)
PSA Sabre-15945
SOLGW M4-89930
SOLGW MK1 CAR930
SOLGW MK1 Recce930
Bear Creek Arsenal BC-9420
Aero Precision EPC-9400

What the figures show overall

Taken as a whole, the ranking shows that empty weight does not reduce these 2020s carbines to one clear pattern of size or intended format. The lightest entry, the Magpul FDP-9, is a 9x19mm Parabellum blowback folding design at 1588 g3. The heaviest, the SOLGW MK1 Recce, is a 5.56x45mm NATO direct-impingement carbine at 3357 g2. The gap between them is 1769 g4.

The middle of the table is more revealing than the endpoints. A PSA Sabre-15 in 5.56x45mm NATO sits at 2948 g9, below the 9x19mm Aero Precision EPC-9 at 3005 g1 and the 9x19mm Bear Creek Arsenal BC-9 at 3084 g8. That overlap matters because it shows that cartridge alone does not determine where a model lands in the order. Operating system and layout differ across those three, with direct impingement on the Sabre-15 and blowback on the EPC-9 and BC-9.

The broader split still remains visible. The four 9x19mm carbines span 1588 g to 3084 g, while the four 5.56x45mm NATO carbines span 2948 g to 3357 g. For the full ranked set and the underlying specifications, see the catalogue’s carbine rankings.

Sources and methods

Footnotes

  1. GunSpec catalogue record for the Aero Precision EPC-9, which cites aeroprecisionusa.com, gunsandammo.com, thetruthaboutguns.com. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5

  2. GunSpec catalogue record for the SOLGW MK1 Recce, which cites sonsoflibertygw.com, sonsoflibertygw.com, web.archive.org. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6

  3. GunSpec catalogue record for the Magpul FDP-9, which cites magpul.com, zevtechnologies.com, ammoland.com, thefirearmblog.com. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5

  4. Method, comparisons: a difference is one catalogue figure minus another of the same kind, in the same unit. Comparisons. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6

  5. GunSpec catalogue record for the SOLGW M4-89, which cites sonsoflibertygw.com, sonsoflibertygw.com, bigtexordnance.com. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  6. GunSpec catalogue record for the CMMG Banshee Mk17, which cites cmmg.com, shootingillustrated.com, guns.com. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  7. GunSpec catalogue record for the SOLGW MK1 CAR, which cites sonsoflibertygw.com, sonsoflibertygw.com, sofrep.com. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2

  8. GunSpec catalogue record for the Bear Creek Arsenal BC-9, which cites thefirearmblog.com, athlonoutdoors.com, gunmagwarehouse.com. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  9. GunSpec catalogue record for the PSA Sabre-15, which cites palmettostatearmory.com, pewpewtactical.com, recoilweb.com, thefirearmblog.com. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  10. GunSpec catalogue record for the 5.56x45mm NATO, which cites bobp.cip-bobp.org. In the API: calibers reference and ammunition reference. ↩

  11. GunSpec catalogue record for the 9x19mm Parabellum, which cites bobp.cip-bobp.org. In the API: calibers reference and ammunition reference. ↩

Discussion