This comparison covers eight carbine models introduced from 20101 to 2017, ranked by recorded empty weight. In this set, the heaviest is the AR57 at 3400 g and the lightest is the CMMG Banshee at 2177 g2. The spread between them is 1223 g3, or about 1.2 kg.
The figures also show that this is not a smooth ladder. There is a tie at 2948 g4 between the Anderson AM-15 and the Wilson Combat AR9 Carbine, while the top end is closely packed, with the B&T APC223 at 3320 g5 and the SIG 516 at 3311 g sitting near the AR57. At the lower end, the Angstadt Arms UDP-9 Rifle at 2722 g6 stands well above the Banshee.
The article uses those weight figures as the starting point, then checks what else changes across the same set: chambering, overall length, barrel length, muzzle velocity and listed effective range. The chart below shows the weight ranking first, then the rest of the catalogue figures explain why equal or near equal mass can still describe quite different carbines.
Empty weight, compared
The data in this chart
| Firearm | Empty weight (g) |
|---|---|
| AR57 | 3,400 |
| B&T APC223 | 3,320 |
| SIG 516 | 3,311 |
| Noveske N4 | 2,950 |
| Anderson AM-15 | 2,948 |
| Wilson Combat AR9 Carbine | 2,948 |
| Angstadt Arms UDP-9 Rifle | 2,722 |
| CMMG Banshee | 2,177 |
The ranking and the spread
By recorded empty weight, the eight 2010s carbines rank as follows:
| Model | Empty weight |
|---|---|
| AR57 | 3400 g |
| B&T APC223 | 3320 g |
| SIG 516 | 3311 g |
| Noveske N4 | 2950 g |
| Anderson AM-15 | 2948 g |
| Wilson Combat AR9 Carbine | 2948 g |
| Angstadt Arms UDP-9 Rifle | 2722 g |
| CMMG Banshee | 2177 g |
The spread from heaviest to lightest is 1223 g3, or about 1.2 kg. That is the basic scale of variation in this set, and it is large enough to separate the group into a heavy upper end, a narrow middle and a distinctly lighter bottom entry.
The top of the ranking is comparatively compressed. The AR57, B&T APC223 and SIG 516 all fall within 89 g of one another. The middle is tighter still: the Noveske N4 at 2950 g4 is only 2 g7 above the Anderson AM-15 and the Wilson Combat AR9 Carbine, which are tied at 2948 g. The chart below makes that clustering clearer than the raw list alone.
Weight does not track one cartridge alone
This set spans three cartridges, 5.56x45mm NATO, 5.7x28mm FN and 9x19mm Parabellum, but the weight ranking does not resolve into a cartridge ranking.
The clearest example is the AR57. It is chambered for 5.7x28mm FN, whose cartridge overall length is 40.5 mm7 in the chart below, yet it is the heaviest firearm in this group at 3400 g1. By contrast, the three 5.56x45mm NATO carbines, with a longer 57.4 mm8 cartridge overall length, spread from 2948 g4 for the Anderson AM-15 to 3320 g5 for the B&T APC223, with the SIG 516 at 3311 g and the Noveske N4 at 2950 g.
The three 9x19mm carbines, using the shortest cartridge here at 29.69 mm9 overall length, also do not form a single narrow band. They run from 2177 g2 for the CMMG Banshee to 2948 g for the Wilson Combat AR9 Carbine, with the Angstadt Arms UDP-9 Rifle at 2722 g6. In this sample, chambering matters, but so do operating system and overall layout.
The cartridges, to scale
Drawn from the recorded case and bullet dimensions, all at one scale.
Source: GET /v1/calibers/5-56x45mm-nato, GET /v1/calibers/5-7x28mm, GET /v1/calibers/9x19mm-parabellum
The data in this chart
| Cartridge | Overall length (mm) |
|---|---|
| 5.56x45mm NATO | 57.4 |
| 5.7x28mm FN | 40.5 |
| 9x19mm Parabellum | 29.7 |
Length and barrel figures help explain the outliers
Length helps explain the main outlier at the bottom of the ranking. The CMMG Banshee, the lightest model here at 2177 g2, is also the shortest by a wide margin: 533 mm overall with a 127 mm barrel. No other carbine in this set is close to that footprint.
Most of the heavier entries sit in a more conventional carbine envelope. The Noveske N4, Anderson AM-15, Angstadt Arms UDP-9 Rifle and SIG 516 run from 838 mm4 to 914 mm10 overall. Their barrels are usually 406 mm1, which is also the figure recorded for the AR57 and the Wilson Combat AR9 Carbine. That common barrel length appears across models weighing from 2722 g6 to 3400 g, so barrel length alone does not account for the ranking.
At the top end, the AR57 pairs the greatest empty weight, 3400 g, with a 406 mm barrel and the largest magazine capacity in the group at 50 rounds. The B&T APC223 is close behind at 3320 g5 with a recorded barrel length of 318 mm, but that barrel figure is under review, so it should be treated as part of the record rather than as the basis for a conclusion.
Velocity and range separate the rifle calibre carbines from the pistol calibre group
The velocity figures divide these carbines into distinct ballistic groups. The three 5.56x45mm NATO models sit at the top of the chart below: the Anderson AM-15 and Noveske N4 are both recorded at 914 m/s4, and the SIG 516 at 905 m/s, with the B&T APC223 close behind at 880 m/s5. All four are also listed with an effective range of 500 m.
Below that sits the AR57, chambered for 5.7x28mm FN, at 716 m/s1 and 100 m effective range. The three 9x19mm Parabellum carbines form the lowest band: the Angstadt Arms UDP-9 Rifle at 420 m/s6, the Wilson Combat AR9 Carbine at 400 m/s11, and the CMMG Banshee at 380 m/s2, each with a listed effective range of 100 m.
This matters when reading the weight ranking. The lighter entries are not reduced-mass versions of the 500 m 5.56 carbines. They belong to a different velocity and range class in the catalogue figures.
Muzzle velocity, compared
The data in this chart
| Firearm | Muzzle velocity (m/s) |
|---|---|
| Anderson AM-15 | 914 |
| Noveske N4 | 914 |
| SIG 516 | 905 |
| B&T APC223 | 880 |
| AR57 | 716 |
| Angstadt Arms UDP-9 Rifle | 420 |
| Wilson Combat AR9 Carbine | 400 |
| CMMG Banshee | 380 |
What the figures show overall
Taken together, the figures sort these eight 2010s carbines into three practical weight clusters. At the top sit the SIG 516 at 3311 g5, the B&T APC223 at 3320 g and the AR57 at 3400 g1. In the middle are the Wilson Combat AR9 Carbine and Anderson AM-15 at 2948 g4, with the Noveske N4 at 2950 g. At the bottom are the Angstadt Arms UDP-9 Rifle at 2722 g6 and the CMMG Banshee at 2177 g2.
The middle cluster is the clearest warning against reading weight as a proxy for one performance class. The Anderson AM-15 and Wilson Combat AR9 Carbine are equal at 2948 g, yet they differ in chambering, 5.56x45mm NATO against 9x19mm Parabellum, in muzzle velocity, 914 m/s against 400 m/s11, and in listed effective range, 500 m against 100 m. The Noveske N4, only 2 g7 heavier than those two, also sits in 5.56x45mm NATO and records 914 m/s and 500 m.
For the full ranked list and the underlying catalogue entries, see the rankings and every carbine in the catalogue.
Sources and methods
Figures under review. The catalogue's own data checks still question one figure in this post, given here as the record states it. How the data is checked.
| Task | Figure | Open question |
|---|---|---|
| View task | B&T APC223 barrel length | Its sources disagree |
Footnotes
-
GunSpec catalogue record for the AR57, which cites atlanticfirearms.com, smallarmsreview.com. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
-
GunSpec catalogue record for the CMMG Banshee, which cites cmmg.com, shootingillustrated.com, cmmg.com, handgunhero.com. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
-
Method, comparisons: a difference is one catalogue figure minus another of the same kind, in the same unit. Comparisons. ↩ ↩2
-
GunSpec catalogue record for the Noveske N4, which cites noveske.com, ar15.com, noveske.com, handgunhero.com. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6
-
GunSpec catalogue record for the B&T APC223, which cites en.wikipedia.org, bt-usa.com, rainierarms.com, atlanticfirearms.com. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
-
GunSpec catalogue record for the Angstadt Arms UDP-9 Rifle, which cites angstadtarms.com, angstadtarms.com, pewpewtactical.com. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
-
GunSpec catalogue record for the 5.7x28mm FN, which cites bobp.cip-bobp.org. In the API: calibers reference and ammunition reference. ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
GunSpec catalogue record for the 5.56x45mm NATO, which cites bobp.cip-bobp.org. In the API: calibers reference and ammunition reference. ↩
-
GunSpec catalogue record for the 9x19mm Parabellum, which cites bobp.cip-bobp.org. In the API: calibers reference and ammunition reference. ↩
-
GunSpec catalogue record for the SIG 516, which cites en.wikipedia.org, sigsauer.com, thetruthaboutguns.com, thefirearmblog.com. In the API: firearms reference. ↩
-
GunSpec catalogue record for the Wilson Combat AR9 Carbine, which cites wilsoncombat.com, americanrifleman.org. In the API: firearms reference. ↩ ↩2
Discussion